|
What
Is Earth Jurisprudence?
©2006, Herman F. Greene, J.D., D.Min., Program Consultant for Center for Earth Jurisprudence Earth Jurisprudence has an affinity with many current fields of law, including environmental law, animal rights law, rights of indigenous people, and jurisprudence. The distinctive features of Earth Jurisprudence are that it looks at law from the standpoint of the health of ecosystems and the role of humans as an integral part of the larger eco-systems. The focus is on how legal norms may be established and disputes may be settled involving human-Earth relations. The field opens the door to fundamental re-thinking of the basis of law. As an inquiry into the basis of law, Earth Jurisprudence falls within the field of jurisprudence. As an inquiry into effective regulation and dispute settlement in matters relating to human-Earth relations, Earth Jurisprudence involves interdisciplinary studies. As an inquiry into how to prepare lawyers to deal with increasingly important issues relating to global ecosystems, resource limitations and environmental health, Earth Jurisprudence involves legal education. Jurisprudence Earth Jurisprudence begins where it has not begun before, at least in the classical Western civilization. It begins with what Cormac Cullinan of EnAct International, Capetown, South Africa, calls the "Great Jurisprudence." The Great Jurisprudence is the laws or principles that govern how the universe functions. Usually we deal with these laws in relation to how Earth functions and in particular how Earth functions to promote and sustain life. By this jurisprudence "nature functioning as it should" provides guidance for human laws and law making. Global warming and other natural disturbances have brought attention to limits we may be crossing that are "beyond political negotiation" (Lester Brown). James Lovelock and others developing "earth system science" offer an understanding of Earth as a "self-regulating system able to keep the climate and chemical composition comfortable for organisms." While the scientific basis for this understanding remains somewhat controversial, it is now generally accepted that we tamper with "nature" at our own risk and that the dynamics of nature must be taken into account in regulating human affairs. Earth Jurisprudence gives explicit recognition to this principle and the "jurisprudence" aspect of Earth Jurisprudence is an inquiry into how this affects the basis of law. Interdisciplinary
Studies The sources of Earth Jurisprudence might be said to lay in Earth "science" or Earth literacy. Science is used here in its broadest sense to mean "knowledge" generally. This knowledge comes from wherever humans have given attention to learning from or about Earth and human relations to Earth. Indigenous societies, unlike classical civilizations, were often oriented to knowledge of Earth's processes and the wisdom of these societies is a source of Earth Jurisprudence. Modern sciences, including physics, geology, mathematics, chemistry and biology, provide knowledge of the operations of Earth and the proper functioning of life systems. Humanistic, philosophic and religious traditions provide insight into moral behavior in relation to other-than-human nature and an understanding of the human place in the universe and how to value human and natural beings in various settings. Earth jurisprudence is a companion of environmental law in seeking to address the health of the environment. It is either different from, or an extension of, environmental law in broadening the field of study of Earth-human relations and their regulation to include Earth science as developed in scientific, humanistic and religious disciplines. Legal
Education Earth
Jurisprudence is a departure from the contemporary law school's emphasis
on teaching students the law that is and how to apply that law as advocates,
administrators or judges. It is an anticipation that today's students
need to be equipped to deal with environmental challenges that are foreseeable,
but for which there may be no contemporary rule or remedy in law. For
example, in a world of biodiversity loss, perhaps a new answer will have
to be found to Christopher's Stones classic question, "Do Trees Have
Standing?" (or river systems, carbon and hydrological cycles, glaciers
or biological hot spots?) Earth Jurisprudence takes on the challenge of
preparing students and lawyers for a future that recognizes the inherent
interdependency of the entire Earth community, which in geo-biological
terms, will not be what it used to be. |